Friday, September 22, 2023
  • SUBSCRIBE NOW
  • Login
  • Register
No Result
View All Result
The Kenya Times
  • News
    • All
    • Africa News
    • Diaspora News
    • East Africa News
    • Middle East News
    • National News
    • West Africa News
    • World News
    Govt Revises Entry Requirements for Teacher Training Colleges

    Relief for Teachers as TSC Rejects Some Proposals Sent to Ruto

    KNH Conducts One-of-a-Kind 16-Hour Delicate Surgery

    KNH Conducts One-of-a-Kind 16-Hour Delicate Surgery

    Rachel Ruto to Launch 'We Are Equal Campaign'

    Rachel Ruto to Launch ‘We Are Equal Campaign’ in Kenya

    KPA Boss Captain William Ruto Announces New Cargo Charges

    Captain William Ruto Announces New Cargo Charges

    LPG Gas Cylinders at a past EPRA operation.

    Kenyans Warned of Fake Cooking Gas Cylinders

    Museveni’s Ex-Aide Blasts Ruto Over Food Insecurity

    Museveni’s Ex-Aide Blasts Ruto Over Food Insecurity

    Trending Tags

    • Business
      • All
      • Banking
      • Cryptocurrency
      • Economy
      • Energy
      • Money Markets
      • Personal Finance
      • Real Estate
      • Startups
      MP Pushes for Hefty Fines of Up to Ksh10M After Migori Gold Rush

      MP Pushes for Hefty Fines of Up to Ksh10M After Migori Gold Rush

      New Features for WhatsApp Business Announced

      New Features for WhatsApp Business Announced

      Kenyans Rush to Tanzania for Cheaper Fuel

      Kenyans Rush to Tanzania for Cheaper Fuel

      Ruto Signs Cheap Fuel Deal with the UAE

      Boost for Ruto as Fuel Deal with UAE Extended

      EPRA Deactivates MPESA Account, Gives Alternative

      Daniel Kiptoo: From Rugby Player to EPRA Boss

      KRA Online Auction for cargo that overstayed at Mombasa port.

      Tax the Rich to Beat Poverty: Kenya’s Extreme Inequality Out of Control

    • Health
      • All
      • Allergies
      • COVID-19
      • Health & Science
      • Mens Health
      • Mental Health
      • Wellness
      • Womens Health
      Public Service PS Amos Gathecha speaking during the opening ceremony of Public Service Counsellors workshop on September 18. PHOTO-Amos

      Govt Identifies Most Stressed Civil Servants

      UJI POWER: Benefits of Popular Sip Keeping Nairobians Full Amid Tough Times

      UJI POWER: Benefits of Popular Sip Keeping Nairobians Full Amid Tough Times

      Doctors to Hold Protests on the State of Healthcare in Kenya

      Doctors to Hold Protests, Issue Demands to Govt

      Worldcoin Eye Scans May Cause Health Complications

      CS Nakhumicha Warns Kenyans of Health Risks Linked to Worldcoin Eye Scans

      The Cabinet resolved to introduce three new funds

      Cabinet Approves Scrapping of NHIF

      The American Psychiatric Association defines anxiety as the anticipation of a future concern

      Managing Anxiety: Practical Strategies for Everyday Life 

      Trending Tags

      • Law & Order
        • All
        • Corruption
        • Courts
        • Crime
        • Cyber Crime
        • Elections
        • Fraud
        • Investigations
        • Military
        • Missing Persons
        • Press Freedom
        • Terrorism
        A photo of Billy Chemirmir- Kenyan man found dead in his prison cell in Texas on Septmber 19, 2023.

        Billy Chemirmir: Kenyan Serial Killer Murdered in US Prison

        Khalwale Proposes Tougher Regulations for Boda Boda Riders

        Law Seeking to Control How Kenyans Sit on Boda Boda Coming

        IG Koome Sued Over Uhuru-Era Killings

        IG Koome Sued Over Uhuru-Era Killings

        Ex-Mungiki Leader Maina Njenga Allegedly Abducted

        Ex-Mungiki Leader Maina Njenga Allegedly Abducted

        Government's Crackdown on Drug Trafficking and Illegal Brews

        Foreigner Nabbed at JKIA With Heroin Worth Ksh3.2M

        Homa Bay MP Peter Kaluma speaks during a media brifing at Parliament Buildings Nairobi.

        Kaluma Gives Way Forward After Supreme Court Ruling on LGBTQ Rights

        Supreme Court Seals Fate of Judge

        Supreme Court Seals Fate of Judge

        An undated photo of Chief Justice Martha Koome.

        Win for LGBTQ as Supreme Court Determines Kaluma Petition

        Court Rules on Pauline Njoroge's Case

        Court Rules on Pauline Njoroge’s Case

        Trending Tags

        • Sports
          • All
          • Athletics
          • Basketball
          • Boxing
          • Cricket
          • Football
          • Formula 1
          • Golf
          • Marathons
          • Olympics
          • Rallies
          • Rugby
          • Tennis
          • World Cup
          From left Barcelona Coach Xavi Hernandez, Manchester City coach Pep Guardiola and Bayern Leverkusen boss Xavi Alonso. The 3 coaches are unbeaten.

          18 Unbeaten Teams in Europe’s Big 5 Leagues in 2023/24 Season

          A Love Story on the Runway: Mary Moraa's Surprise Airport Proposal

          Lucky Man Melts Mary Moraa’s Golden Heart with Airport Proposal

          President Ruto Awards Shujaa 7s Players Ksh200k Each

          Ruto Awards Shujaa 7s Players Ksh200k Each

          Image of CS Namwamba with President Ruto at a past event. PHOTO- CS Namwamba

          I am Not Resigning Anytime Soon – Ababu Namwamba

          Image of CS Namwamba with President Ruto at a past event. PHOTO- CS Namwamba

          Ababu Namwamba Brags of His Unbeaten Record

          CS Ababu Namwamba on the Spot Over His Performance

          Our Eyes Are on World Cup, Namwamba After Harambee Stars Beating

          Trending Tags

          • Entertainment
            • All
            • Gaming
            • Movies
            • Music
            Sonko's Emotional Message to Daughter as She Flies Out

            Sonko’s Emotional Message to Daughter as She Flies Out

            Abel Mutua Issues 'Joint Statement' After Kate Actress Divorce

            Abel Mutua Issues ‘Joint Statement’ After Kate Actress Divorce

            A collage of Kenyan Singer and Songwriter Nadia Mukami.

            Nadia Mukami Bags Prestigious Award in US

            A past photo of content creator Andrew Kibe.

            Google Breaks Silence on Andrew Kibe YouTube Channel

            Pulse Kenya stated that there are fraudulent players contacting 2023 nominees for pulse awards offering them votes at a price

            Pulse Kenya Condemns Fraudsters Selling Votes to Influencer Award Nominees

            Otile Brown Calls Out Diamond and Mbosso Over Fake Jewelry

            Otile Brown Calls Out Diamond and Mbosso Over Fake Jewelry

            Trending Tags

            • Lifestyle
              • All
              • Arts
              • Culture
              • Disabilities Matters
              • Ethics & Religion
              • Family
              • Fashion
              • Food
              • Human Interest
              • Tourism
              Ruto Under Pressure to Introduce One-Child Policy in Kenya

              Ruto Under Pressure to Introduce One-Child Policy in Kenya

              Inclusive Initiatives to Support Mobility for PWDs In Kenya

              Inclusive Initiatives to Support Mobility for PWDs In Kenya

              Sam Gituku: From Unknown Radio Reporter to High-Flying TV Anchor

              Sam Gituku: From Unknown Radio Reporter to High-Flying TV Anchor

              Dr. Kelvin Shikuku. PHOTO/Courtesy.

              Kenyan Feted by European Research Body After Emerging Top

              Diet Tips: What You Should Know Before Eating Matumbo

              Diet Tips: What You Should Know Before Eating Matumbo

              Wahu Recalls Losing 2 Pregnancies as Daughter Turns 10 Months

              Wahu Recalls Losing 2 Pregnancies as Daughter Turns 10 Months

              Trending Tags

              • Sci-Tech
                • All
                • Climate Changes
                • Cyber Security
                • Social Media
                • Space
                • Technology
                Elon Musk's Neuralink Chip That can Help You Control a Cursor With Your Mind

                Brain Chip That Can Help You Control Computer Cursor with Your Mind Approved

                With pressure from the European Union, Apple has thrown in the towel on its Lightning connector, left, in favor of the standard USB-C, right. Frederic J. Brown/AFP via Getty Images

                What is USB-C?

                President William Ruto (center) poses for a photo with US Ambassador to Kenya Meg Whitman (right) and a Starlink executive after a meetig on September 16, 2023.

                Ruto Pushes for Cheaper Internet in Meeting with Elon Musk’s Starlink

                Dr. Kelvin Shikuku. PHOTO/Courtesy.

                Kenyan Feted by European Research Body After Emerging Top

                Met Department Warns of El Nino Rains

                NEMA Sounds Warning to Businessowners

                Nairobi Declaration on Climate Change and Call to Action

                Details of Resolutions Adopted by African Presidents in Nairobi

                Trending Tags

                • Opinion
                  • All
                  • Editorials
                  • John Mukum Mbaku
                  • Letters to Editor
                  • Makau Mutua
                  • Peter Ongera
                  • Salim Lone
                  • XN Iraki
                  Wagner group founder Yevgeny Prigozhin, photographed on June 24, 2023, in Russia. Anadolu Agency via Getty Images

                  Wagner Group: What Yevgeny Prigozhin’s Death Means for Stability in Africa

                  Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis speaks during a news conference after former President Donald Trump’s Aug. 15 indictments. Joe Raedle/Getty Images

                  RICO is Often Used to Target the Mob and Cartels

                  Niger coup and Junta leader Gen Abdourahmane Tchiani; part of a demonstration held by his supporters in Niamey on Sunday. Coutesy of Balima Boreima / Anadolu Agency via Getty Images

                  The Needless Return of the Coup

                  The indictment of Donald Trump and an aide was ‘laced with rhetorical and narrative techniques.’ Photo Illustration by Drew Angerer/Getty Images

                  Trump’s Classified-Documents Indictment Does More than Allege Crimes

                  Wagner group founder Yevgeny Prigozhin, photographed on June 24, 2023, in Russia. Anadolu Agency via Getty Images

                  Wagner Group’s Yevgeny Prigozhin Reportedly Died in Private Jet Crash

                  Africa is facing a lot of challenges.

                  Africa Must Chart Its Leadership Separate from Foreign Ideology

                • Contact Us
                • News
                  • All
                  • Africa News
                  • Diaspora News
                  • East Africa News
                  • Middle East News
                  • National News
                  • West Africa News
                  • World News
                  Govt Revises Entry Requirements for Teacher Training Colleges

                  Relief for Teachers as TSC Rejects Some Proposals Sent to Ruto

                  KNH Conducts One-of-a-Kind 16-Hour Delicate Surgery

                  KNH Conducts One-of-a-Kind 16-Hour Delicate Surgery

                  Rachel Ruto to Launch 'We Are Equal Campaign'

                  Rachel Ruto to Launch ‘We Are Equal Campaign’ in Kenya

                  KPA Boss Captain William Ruto Announces New Cargo Charges

                  Captain William Ruto Announces New Cargo Charges

                  LPG Gas Cylinders at a past EPRA operation.

                  Kenyans Warned of Fake Cooking Gas Cylinders

                  Museveni’s Ex-Aide Blasts Ruto Over Food Insecurity

                  Museveni’s Ex-Aide Blasts Ruto Over Food Insecurity

                  Trending Tags

                  • Business
                    • All
                    • Banking
                    • Cryptocurrency
                    • Economy
                    • Energy
                    • Money Markets
                    • Personal Finance
                    • Real Estate
                    • Startups
                    MP Pushes for Hefty Fines of Up to Ksh10M After Migori Gold Rush

                    MP Pushes for Hefty Fines of Up to Ksh10M After Migori Gold Rush

                    New Features for WhatsApp Business Announced

                    New Features for WhatsApp Business Announced

                    Kenyans Rush to Tanzania for Cheaper Fuel

                    Kenyans Rush to Tanzania for Cheaper Fuel

                    Ruto Signs Cheap Fuel Deal with the UAE

                    Boost for Ruto as Fuel Deal with UAE Extended

                    EPRA Deactivates MPESA Account, Gives Alternative

                    Daniel Kiptoo: From Rugby Player to EPRA Boss

                    KRA Online Auction for cargo that overstayed at Mombasa port.

                    Tax the Rich to Beat Poverty: Kenya’s Extreme Inequality Out of Control

                  • Health
                    • All
                    • Allergies
                    • COVID-19
                    • Health & Science
                    • Mens Health
                    • Mental Health
                    • Wellness
                    • Womens Health
                    Public Service PS Amos Gathecha speaking during the opening ceremony of Public Service Counsellors workshop on September 18. PHOTO-Amos

                    Govt Identifies Most Stressed Civil Servants

                    UJI POWER: Benefits of Popular Sip Keeping Nairobians Full Amid Tough Times

                    UJI POWER: Benefits of Popular Sip Keeping Nairobians Full Amid Tough Times

                    Doctors to Hold Protests on the State of Healthcare in Kenya

                    Doctors to Hold Protests, Issue Demands to Govt

                    Worldcoin Eye Scans May Cause Health Complications

                    CS Nakhumicha Warns Kenyans of Health Risks Linked to Worldcoin Eye Scans

                    The Cabinet resolved to introduce three new funds

                    Cabinet Approves Scrapping of NHIF

                    The American Psychiatric Association defines anxiety as the anticipation of a future concern

                    Managing Anxiety: Practical Strategies for Everyday Life 

                    Trending Tags

                    • Law & Order
                      • All
                      • Corruption
                      • Courts
                      • Crime
                      • Cyber Crime
                      • Elections
                      • Fraud
                      • Investigations
                      • Military
                      • Missing Persons
                      • Press Freedom
                      • Terrorism
                      A photo of Billy Chemirmir- Kenyan man found dead in his prison cell in Texas on Septmber 19, 2023.

                      Billy Chemirmir: Kenyan Serial Killer Murdered in US Prison

                      Khalwale Proposes Tougher Regulations for Boda Boda Riders

                      Law Seeking to Control How Kenyans Sit on Boda Boda Coming

                      IG Koome Sued Over Uhuru-Era Killings

                      IG Koome Sued Over Uhuru-Era Killings

                      Ex-Mungiki Leader Maina Njenga Allegedly Abducted

                      Ex-Mungiki Leader Maina Njenga Allegedly Abducted

                      Government's Crackdown on Drug Trafficking and Illegal Brews

                      Foreigner Nabbed at JKIA With Heroin Worth Ksh3.2M

                      Homa Bay MP Peter Kaluma speaks during a media brifing at Parliament Buildings Nairobi.

                      Kaluma Gives Way Forward After Supreme Court Ruling on LGBTQ Rights

                      Supreme Court Seals Fate of Judge

                      Supreme Court Seals Fate of Judge

                      An undated photo of Chief Justice Martha Koome.

                      Win for LGBTQ as Supreme Court Determines Kaluma Petition

                      Court Rules on Pauline Njoroge's Case

                      Court Rules on Pauline Njoroge’s Case

                      Trending Tags

                      • Sports
                        • All
                        • Athletics
                        • Basketball
                        • Boxing
                        • Cricket
                        • Football
                        • Formula 1
                        • Golf
                        • Marathons
                        • Olympics
                        • Rallies
                        • Rugby
                        • Tennis
                        • World Cup
                        From left Barcelona Coach Xavi Hernandez, Manchester City coach Pep Guardiola and Bayern Leverkusen boss Xavi Alonso. The 3 coaches are unbeaten.

                        18 Unbeaten Teams in Europe’s Big 5 Leagues in 2023/24 Season

                        A Love Story on the Runway: Mary Moraa's Surprise Airport Proposal

                        Lucky Man Melts Mary Moraa’s Golden Heart with Airport Proposal

                        President Ruto Awards Shujaa 7s Players Ksh200k Each

                        Ruto Awards Shujaa 7s Players Ksh200k Each

                        Image of CS Namwamba with President Ruto at a past event. PHOTO- CS Namwamba

                        I am Not Resigning Anytime Soon – Ababu Namwamba

                        Image of CS Namwamba with President Ruto at a past event. PHOTO- CS Namwamba

                        Ababu Namwamba Brags of His Unbeaten Record

                        CS Ababu Namwamba on the Spot Over His Performance

                        Our Eyes Are on World Cup, Namwamba After Harambee Stars Beating

                        Trending Tags

                        • Entertainment
                          • All
                          • Gaming
                          • Movies
                          • Music
                          Sonko's Emotional Message to Daughter as She Flies Out

                          Sonko’s Emotional Message to Daughter as She Flies Out

                          Abel Mutua Issues 'Joint Statement' After Kate Actress Divorce

                          Abel Mutua Issues ‘Joint Statement’ After Kate Actress Divorce

                          A collage of Kenyan Singer and Songwriter Nadia Mukami.

                          Nadia Mukami Bags Prestigious Award in US

                          A past photo of content creator Andrew Kibe.

                          Google Breaks Silence on Andrew Kibe YouTube Channel

                          Pulse Kenya stated that there are fraudulent players contacting 2023 nominees for pulse awards offering them votes at a price

                          Pulse Kenya Condemns Fraudsters Selling Votes to Influencer Award Nominees

                          Otile Brown Calls Out Diamond and Mbosso Over Fake Jewelry

                          Otile Brown Calls Out Diamond and Mbosso Over Fake Jewelry

                          Trending Tags

                          • Lifestyle
                            • All
                            • Arts
                            • Culture
                            • Disabilities Matters
                            • Ethics & Religion
                            • Family
                            • Fashion
                            • Food
                            • Human Interest
                            • Tourism
                            Ruto Under Pressure to Introduce One-Child Policy in Kenya

                            Ruto Under Pressure to Introduce One-Child Policy in Kenya

                            Inclusive Initiatives to Support Mobility for PWDs In Kenya

                            Inclusive Initiatives to Support Mobility for PWDs In Kenya

                            Sam Gituku: From Unknown Radio Reporter to High-Flying TV Anchor

                            Sam Gituku: From Unknown Radio Reporter to High-Flying TV Anchor

                            Dr. Kelvin Shikuku. PHOTO/Courtesy.

                            Kenyan Feted by European Research Body After Emerging Top

                            Diet Tips: What You Should Know Before Eating Matumbo

                            Diet Tips: What You Should Know Before Eating Matumbo

                            Wahu Recalls Losing 2 Pregnancies as Daughter Turns 10 Months

                            Wahu Recalls Losing 2 Pregnancies as Daughter Turns 10 Months

                            Trending Tags

                            • Sci-Tech
                              • All
                              • Climate Changes
                              • Cyber Security
                              • Social Media
                              • Space
                              • Technology
                              Elon Musk's Neuralink Chip That can Help You Control a Cursor With Your Mind

                              Brain Chip That Can Help You Control Computer Cursor with Your Mind Approved

                              With pressure from the European Union, Apple has thrown in the towel on its Lightning connector, left, in favor of the standard USB-C, right. Frederic J. Brown/AFP via Getty Images

                              What is USB-C?

                              President William Ruto (center) poses for a photo with US Ambassador to Kenya Meg Whitman (right) and a Starlink executive after a meetig on September 16, 2023.

                              Ruto Pushes for Cheaper Internet in Meeting with Elon Musk’s Starlink

                              Dr. Kelvin Shikuku. PHOTO/Courtesy.

                              Kenyan Feted by European Research Body After Emerging Top

                              Met Department Warns of El Nino Rains

                              NEMA Sounds Warning to Businessowners

                              Nairobi Declaration on Climate Change and Call to Action

                              Details of Resolutions Adopted by African Presidents in Nairobi

                              Trending Tags

                              • Opinion
                                • All
                                • Editorials
                                • John Mukum Mbaku
                                • Letters to Editor
                                • Makau Mutua
                                • Peter Ongera
                                • Salim Lone
                                • XN Iraki
                                Wagner group founder Yevgeny Prigozhin, photographed on June 24, 2023, in Russia. Anadolu Agency via Getty Images

                                Wagner Group: What Yevgeny Prigozhin’s Death Means for Stability in Africa

                                Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis speaks during a news conference after former President Donald Trump’s Aug. 15 indictments. Joe Raedle/Getty Images

                                RICO is Often Used to Target the Mob and Cartels

                                Niger coup and Junta leader Gen Abdourahmane Tchiani; part of a demonstration held by his supporters in Niamey on Sunday. Coutesy of Balima Boreima / Anadolu Agency via Getty Images

                                The Needless Return of the Coup

                                The indictment of Donald Trump and an aide was ‘laced with rhetorical and narrative techniques.’ Photo Illustration by Drew Angerer/Getty Images

                                Trump’s Classified-Documents Indictment Does More than Allege Crimes

                                Wagner group founder Yevgeny Prigozhin, photographed on June 24, 2023, in Russia. Anadolu Agency via Getty Images

                                Wagner Group’s Yevgeny Prigozhin Reportedly Died in Private Jet Crash

                                Africa is facing a lot of challenges.

                                Africa Must Chart Its Leadership Separate from Foreign Ideology

                              • Contact Us
                              No Result
                              View All Result
                              The Kenya Times ~ Breaking News, Business, Politics, Sports and Entertainment
                              No Result
                              View All Result

                              Gareth Evans: The Case for Recognizing Palestine

                              Gareth Evans by Gareth Evans
                              June 19, 2023
                              A Palestinian protester rests during clashes with Israeli troops after a demonstration against Israel’s settlements, near Nablus, West Bank, June 9, 2023 | Alaa Badarneh/EPA

                              A Palestinian protester rests during clashes with Israeli troops after a demonstration against Israel’s settlements, near Nablus, West Bank, June 9, 2023 | Alaa Badarneh/EPA

                              Since a United Nations General Assembly Resolution vote in November 2012, Palestine has had the status of a state within the UN system. It is not a full member state but, like the Holy See, a non-member observer state. Australia – after a heady debate within the Gillard cabinet – abstained on that vote.

                              The State of Palestine has now been recognized as such by 138 of the UN’s 193 members, over 70% of the total. But Australia – along with the United States and most of its allies and partners – is not one of them.

                              Labor’s policy is now clearly that this should change. Initially passed in the form of a National Conference Resolution in 2018, then elevated to formal incorporation in the National Platform in 2021 on the motion of then shadow minister Penny Wong, the language is unequivocal:

                              The Party supports the recognition and right of Israel and Palestine to exist as two states within secure and recognized borders; calls on the next Labor Government to recognize Palestine as a state; and expects that this issue will be an important priority for the next Labor government.

                              But unequivocal platform language, as most of us who have been in this business are acutely aware, has never stopped Labor governments equivocating. That has been the case whenever they – we – have had cost-benefit doubts about the practical, principled or political wisdom of some party policy position. There has been no sign yet that the Albanese government is giving the issue any priority at all.

                              So the question for us now is whether any further equivocation on this issue is in fact justified, or whether it is time for Australia to grasp the moment and explicitly recognize Palestinian statehood.

                              I believe we should, but the case has to be argued, not just asserted. The counter arguments need to be met head-on. There are three dimensions to the debate – moral, legal and political – and I will look at each in turn.

                              There has been no sign yet that the Albanese government is giving the issue of Palestinian statehood any priority | Lucas Coch/AAP

                              The moral argument

                              The moral argument is the easiest to make: the righting of a grievous wrong done to Jewish people does not justify a grievous wrong being done to Palestinian people.

                              For what it’s worth, it was that perception – which first struck home to me when I read, as a university student in the 1960s, the classic Penguin Special Israel and the Arabs by the French historian Maxime Rodinson, both of whose parents were murdered in Auschwitz – which triggered my understanding of the Palestinian cause. It has been key to my support for it ever since.

                              Everyone understands the nature and force of the Jewish people’s claim to a recognized homeland with safe and secure borders, suffering as they did centuries of persecution, culminating in the horror of the Holocaust.


                              Also Read: The Harvard of Anti-Terrorism: How Israel’s Military-Industrial Complex Feeds the Global Arms Trade


                              But it is equally impossible to ignore the moral force of the Palestinian response: that the world’s conscience should not be satisfied at the expense of a people who bear no responsibility for that suffering.

                              Palestinians deserved a state of their own. They were promised a state of their own by the UN General Assembly in 1947 in its resolution – which Australia’s H.V. Evatt played a crucial role in crafting – to partition the then-British Mandate of Palestine into two states: one Arab and one Jewish, with Jerusalem to be placed under a special international regime.

                              The design and implementation of the Partition Plan was only defensible if it involved, as its terms clearly did, no dispossession of Palestinians living in the new Jewish state, and no subsequent discrimination against them, and the same for Jews in the new Palestinian state.

                              But we now know all too well that the birth of Israel, and its whole subsequent history, was accompanied by no such restraint.

                              In the first Arab-Israeli War of 1948, triggered by Palestinian refusal to accept partition, the map was dramatically redrawn in Israel’s favour: 750,000 Palestinians became refugees.

                              In the Six-Day War of 1967, initiated by Israel as a “pre-emptive strike” against its Arab neighbors, East Jerusalem was illegally annexed. The remaining 22% of the former Palestine was militarily occupied, and the foundations were laid for what it is hard now to describe as anything other than an apartheid state – certainly so in the occupied West Bank, and only marginally less so now in Israel itself.

                              The Palestinian Declaration of Independence of November 1988, which referenced the original Partition Plan and subsequent UN resolutions, effectively recognised Israel and supported a two-state solution. But all subsequent attempts to implement such a solution, based on Israel withdrawing to its pre-1967 borders, have run into the sand.

                              Did Palestinians, and the Arab states supporting them, forfeit their moral claim to a state of their own by refusing for so long to accept the Partition Plan and initiating the violent resistance to the creation of Israel that ended so catastrophically in 1948?

                              That is an argument still heard from time to time – and it may seem to have some prima facie plausibility.

                              But if one is going to claim that, how could one not also accept that the moral claim to a new state of Israel was not tarnished by the violent extremism perpetrated by Irgun and the Stern Gang (or Lehi) in the pre-partition period, not least with the bombing of the King David Hotel in 1946 and the massacre at Deir Yassin in April 1948?

                              History teaches us it has forever been the unhappy reality that, in the pursuit of national self-determination, some of those most passionate for their causes have sometimes done things that have been misguided and counterproductive, and sometimes indefensibly terrible.

                              But the means chosen cannot in itself destroy the moral force, such as it is, of the end being fought for.

                              Refugees on the road from Jerusalem to Lebanon, November 9, 1948 | Jim Pringle/AP

                              The legal argument

                              The UN Partition Resolution 181(II) of 1947 determined there was to be a Palestinian state alongside the Jewish one. Multiple resolutions since have reaffirmed the UN’s position. While general assembly – unlike security council – resolutions are not formally binding on member states, they are certainly persuasive: both politically and legally.

                              The boundaries of what that Palestinian state might be were effectively redrawn in 1948. They will necessarily require further renegotiation after the new facts on the ground created by the 1967 war and – illegal under international law as they may be – by Israel’s relentless subsequent program of settlement building in East Jerusalem and the West Bank.

                              But the UN has never resiled from declaring the necessity of a two-state solution, in which Palestine would have its own viable, recognized state.

                              Resolutions 242 (after the 1967 War) and 338 (after the 1973 Arab-Israeli War) – constantly reaffirmed since – make clear what the parameters of that solution should involve. They would include Israeli withdrawal from occupied territories and “a just settlement of the refugee problem”.

                              But what is necessary in international law for a state to be recognized as such? And to what extent, if at all, is Australia constrained by that law in making its own recognition decision?

                              The issue is more complicated than it is sometimes claimed to be: there is in fact no single, universally accepted definition in international law as to what constitutes a state.

                              The definition in the 1933 Montevideo Convention on the Rights and Duties of States (ratified by 17 states in the Americas) is the familiar starting point. But it is by no means the finishing point.

                              Article 1 of the Montevideo Convention provides that

                              the state as a person of international law should possess the following qualifications: a) a permanent population; b) a defined territory; c) government; and d) capacity to enter into relations with other states.

                              Palestine does have, arguably, an identifiable population and its own government – albeit divided between the Palestinian Authority and Hamas, with neither in complete effective control of the territory they notionally govern. It does have theoretically defined territory – in the sense of the pre-1967 borders recognized by the UN – but those boundaries now are hardly recognizable in reality. They will be immensely difficult to recreate.

                              And while there remains far from universal acceptance by others of its sovereign equality, Palestine has demonstrated its capacity to enter into relations with other states.

                              It has done this by being accepted (as the State of Palestine, or the Palestine National Authority, or in some cases the PLO) as a full member of a number of international organizations: from the Arab League and Organisation of Islamic Cooperation to the International Telecommunication Union and World Health Organization. And it is accepted as an observer state in others, including the UN itself. It is also a state party to the Rome Statute, which constitutes the International Criminal Court.

                              Not everyone will be persuaded that all the Montevideo criteria are fully satisfied in the case of Palestine. This is obviously the case with organizations here like the Zionist Federation, which has made this a major objection, arguing that claims Palestine meets the minimum criteria for statehood is a “virtue-signaling” pretense.

                              But that is not the end of the story. The view that satisfying these criteria is both necessary and sufficient for a state to be regarded as such is just one school of thought in international law: the “declaratory” school. The other school – described as the “constitutive” school – takes the view that it is the act of recognition by others that leads to the creation of a state.

                              The argument here is partly that the Montevideo criteria cannot be regarded as the sole determinant of statehood: without the additional element of recognition, would-be states would lack international personality and would be unable to benefit from their international rights.

                              But the “constitutive” position goes further: it is recognition itself which really matters. And in the case of Palestine, while its recognition as a state by others is not yet universal, the fact that 138 UN member states (with Mexico reported as likely to be the 139th) now explicitly recognize its statehood is in itself a compelling legal – not just political – argument for others to do the same. 

                              Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu chairs a cabinet meeting in Jerusalem, June 11, 2023 | Menahem Kahana/AP

                              The political argument

                              If the moral arguments for Australian recognition are compelling, and the legal arguments against it anything but decisive, the argument – no surprise – comes down to politics: both international and domestic.

                              There are three international political arguments against our recognition that need to be countered: that recognition by anyone will destroy the peace process; that it is now useless; and that for Australia it would be damaging to our international reputation. Domestically, the argument is that it would be political folly for any party to go down this path.

                              The argument that recognition would destroy the peace process – undermining the capacity for a settlement to be negotiated, and completely premature to even contemplate until such a settlement is achieved – has been around forever.

                              If it ever had any objective credibility with anyone, it certainly has none at all now in the face of Israel’s breathtaking intransigence, being taken to ever more alarming new heights by the Netanyahu government. If the two-state solution is in fact dead, it is the Israeli settlement program that has killed it.

                              There will still be those who lay all the blame for the effective collapse of peace negotiations on a Palestinian regime that former Labor MP Michael Danby, with his usual flair for constructive diplomacy, described earlier this year as “homophobic, fundamentally undemocratic, kleptocratic, misogynist” and “scumbag”.

                              No one doubts that the quality of Palestinian Authority leadership has been less than ideal, nor that Hamas’s formal (if not practical) position on Israel’s right to exist has been manifestly unhelpful.

                              But the evidence is clear – and my own years of direct talking with all parties, particularly as president of the International Crisis Group, strongly confirms it. The threat and reality of violence, whether by Hamas or anyone else, diminishes rapidly when Palestinians see a path ahead of genuine hope for a just and dignified settlement. And it escalates equally rapidly when they do not.

                              The argument that recognition is useless has gained more traction as hopes for a viable two-state solution continue to crumble – above all, as a result of the territorial fragmentation created by Israel’s indefensible West Bank settlement-building program.

                              What is the point, opponents say, of wasting time and energy – and, perhaps, political capital – on supporting a totally quixotic enterprise, never likely to bear fruit?

                              With all that acknowledged, it is important to keep the dream of a two-state solution alive. Not just because it remains overwhelmingly the preferred policy internationally, but because it is so obviously in Israel’s own long-term interest.

                              As many commentators over the years have pointed out, with compelling logic, Israel can be a Jewish state, a democratic state, and one occupying the whole of historical Judea and Samaria. But it cannot be all three.

                              The argument in this context for recognizing Palestinian statehood is that it is crucially necessary to restore a balance that has in recent years tipped overwhelmingly in favor of Israel.

                              No peace negotiation has much prospect of succeeding if the parties at the table are completely mismatched. And the best – possibly the only – way to counter that for the foreseeable future will be for Palestine to show it has ever-increasing legitimacy internationally, not only in the Islamic world and global south, but among traditional pillars of the global north, like Australia and other allies and partners of the United States.

                              For Australia to climb off the fence on this issue would make a significant contribution to changing this dynamic. Giving Palestine some extra leverage and bargaining power is important and useful, whether or not the two-state solution proves to have any life left in it at all.

                              If it does, as we must all hope it does, this will be crucial in producing genuinely just and viable solutions to all the crucial outstanding issues, including boundaries, credible security guarantees for both sides, protection of the holy sites, and a formula that will credibly address the incredibly difficult issue of refugee rights.

                              If it does not – if the two-state solution is indeed permanently dead – and the only game left in town is the negotiation of a new, democratic, non-apartheid-cursed single state (into which the Palestinian population of the West Bank and Gaza is merged with fully equal rights to citizenship with Israel’s own Jewish population) then again anything that gives the Palestinians some more balanced power at the negotiating table is a consummation devoutly to be wished.

                              The argument that recognition would be reputationally damaging for Australia internationally has little to commend it. It is true it would place us outside our usual North America-Western Europe comfort zone (our fellow middle power and good international citizen role model Sweden excepted). But not in a way that could be expected to have any adverse impact on our diplomatic, defense, trade, investment or other national interests.

                              Supporting Palestinian statehood would put us in very good company with most of our global partners in the middle-power MIKTA group, comprising Mexico, Indonesia, Korea and Turkey, as well as ourselves. And more importantly, it will align us with not just Indonesia, but nearly all of our Southeast and South Asian neighbors, and key Pacific partners like Papua New Guinea.

                              If Australia’s future does indeed lie much more with our geography than our Anglospheric history – as I for one have long believed it does – recognition would be no bad call.

                              A mural painted on destroyed houses by Palestinian artists as part of an exhibition entitled ‘Occupation Kills Childhood’, Gaza, June 8, 2023 | Mohammed Saber/EPA

                              Domestic politics

                              Which leaves us, last but by no means least, with the domestic politics. None of us in any party – not least my own – is oblivious to the formidable lobbying power of the Israeli support organizations in this country, nor of their ability to characterize even the most cautiously expressed critiques of Israel as savoring of unconscionable anti-semitism.

                              But times are changing. Israel’s brand – long gradually diminishing, as its practices in the West Bank have been ever more credibly labelled as apartheid by internationally credible observers, from Jimmy Carter to Human Rights Watch – has been badly tarnished in recent times, here as elsewhere, by the extreme, overtly racist, right-wing extremism of the Netanyahu government.

                              There have been massive community demonstrations in Israel against some of its proposed measures – in particular to bring the judiciary to heel. But the democracy being campaigned for does not extend (some brave dissenting voices notwithstanding) to Palestinians living in Israel or under its control.


                              Also Read: New Era of Turkey Israel Brotherhood


                              Within the Jewish community here, as in the US, new and more balanced voices are emerging – like the New Israel Fund. And the voices in Australian politics that have been most visibly arguing for recognition, such as former New South Wales premier and foreign minister Bob Carr, are hardly fringe dwellers outside the respectable mainstream.

                              Bob Hawke, an early very passionate friend of Israel, made abundantly clear as prime minister that it should accept the reality of Palestine’s aspirations to statehood. And, in his later years, he made equally clear his view that Australia should not hold back on recognition.

                              I myself have always supported Israel’s right to exist. And in fact as foreign minister, I resisted international efforts through the UN to characterize any support for Zionism as inherently and irretrievably racist. I have a plaque signed by Mark Leibler of the Zionist Federation of Australia to prove it!

                              What unites me and Hawke and Carr, and a legion of other Labor figures going back to Evatt, is not a belief that Israel should not exist, but that it should fully respect the rights of Palestinians to live alongside it in peace and dignity in a state of their own, and with the rights of dispossessed Palestinians appropriately acknowledged.

                              Maybe recognizing Palestine statehood will put at risk some of our strongest traditional sources of party fundraising. But sometimes those considerations just have to take second place to decency. It is not a bad principle in politics – when in doubt – to do the right thing simply because it’s the right thing to do.


                              This article was delivered as an address to Parliamentary Friends of Palestine, Parliament House, Canberra, June 13 2023.The Conversation

                              Gareth Evans, Distinguished Honorary Professor, Australian National University

                              This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

                              Tags: Foreign PolicyInternational AffairsIsraelIsrael 1948Israel. PalestinePalestine

                              Get real time update about this post categories directly on your device, subscribe now.

                              Unsubscribe
                              Gareth Evans

                              Gareth Evans

                              Professor the Hon Gareth Evans AC KC was a Cabinet Minister throughout the Hawke-Keating Governments, including as Foreign Minister from 1988-96, where he played central roles in the creation of APEC and the ASEAN Regional Forum, the Cambodian peace process, and in bringing to conclusion the Chemical Weapon Convention. From 2000 to 2009 he was President and CEO of the Brussels-based International Crisis Group, and from 2010 to 2019 served as Chancellor of the Australian National University, where he is now Distinguished Honorary Professor. He has co-chaired two major commissions, the International Commissions on Intervention and State Sovereignty (2001) and on Nuclear Non-Proliferation and Disarmament (2009), and has written or edited, singly or jointly, fourteen books – including Good International Citizenship: The Case for Decency (2022), Incorrigible Optimist: A Political Memoir (2017), Nuclear Weapons: The State of Play (2015), Inside the Hawke-Keating Government: A Cabinet Diary (2014), The Responsibility to Protect: Ending Mass Atrocity Crimes Once and for All (2009) and Australia’s Foreign Relations (1991, 1995). In June 2008, he was made an Inaugural Fellow of the Australian Institute of International Affairs in recognition of his outstanding contribution to Australian international relations. He has received a number of national and international honours, most recently, in May 2023, the ROK Jeju Peace Prize for his significant contribution over three decades to promoting peace, reconciliation and human rights as foreign minister, NGO head, international commission member, writer and advocate. Gareth Evans has maintained strong academic and scholarly connections throughout his career, lecturing at many universities around the world. In May 2004, he was elected as an Honorary Fellow of Magdalen College, Oxford, and is a member of the International Advisory Board of UN Studies at Yale; the Advisory Council of the Institute for International Studies at Stanford; and the Editorial Advisory Board of the Cambridge Review of International Affairs.

                              Next Post
                              "You need to decide if you are a media station or an opposition party" Cs Kuria to Nation Media

Photo Courtesy

                              "You Need to Decide if you are a Media Station or an Opposition Party" Cs Kuria to Nation Media

                              Discussion about this post

                              ADVERTISEMENT

                              RECENT NEWS

                              The Teachers Service Commission (TSC) CEO Nancy Macharia

                              TSC Deregisters 73 Teachers Including Those on Boards

                              September 22, 2023
                              From left Barcelona Coach Xavi Hernandez, Manchester City coach Pep Guardiola and Bayern Leverkusen boss Xavi Alonso. The 3 coaches are unbeaten.

                              18 Unbeaten Teams in Europe’s Big 5 Leagues in 2023/24 Season

                              September 22, 2023
                              Govt Revises Entry Requirements for Teacher Training Colleges

                              Relief for Teachers as TSC Rejects Some Proposals Sent to Ruto

                              September 22, 2023
                              KNH Conducts One-of-a-Kind 16-Hour Delicate Surgery

                              KNH Conducts One-of-a-Kind 16-Hour Delicate Surgery

                              September 22, 2023
                              Rachel Ruto to Launch 'We Are Equal Campaign'

                              Rachel Ruto to Launch ‘We Are Equal Campaign’ in Kenya

                              September 22, 2023
                              KPA Boss Captain William Ruto Announces New Cargo Charges

                              Captain William Ruto Announces New Cargo Charges

                              September 22, 2023

                              THE MOST IMPORTANT NATIONAL AND GLOBAL NEWS OF THE DAY

                              Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates direct to your inbox!

                              Join our WhatsApp: WhatsApp News Channel
                              Call us: +254 714 544 390

                              © 2023 The Kenya Times | Contact Us | Privacy Policy | Standards & Policies | House Rules

                              • Login
                              • Sign Up
                              • Cart
                              Subscribe Now
                              No Result
                              View All Result
                              • News
                                • Africa News
                                • Diaspora News
                                • East Africa News
                                • Middle East News
                                • National News
                                • World News
                              • Business
                                • Banking
                                • Cryptocurrency
                                • Economy
                                • Energy
                                • Money Markets
                                • Startups
                                • Real Estate
                                • Technology
                              • Health
                                • COVID-19
                                • Health & Science
                                • Mens Health
                                • Mental Health
                                • Wellness
                                • Womens Health
                              • Law & Order
                                • Cyber Crime
                                • Corruption
                                • Courts
                                • Financial Fraud
                                • Investigations
                                • Missing Persons
                                • Terrorism
                              • Sports
                                • Athletics
                                • Basketball
                                • Boxing
                                • Cricket
                                • Football
                                • Formula 1
                                • Golf
                                • Marathons
                                • Olympics
                                • Rugby
                                • World Cup
                              • Entertainment
                                • Gaming
                                • Music
                                • Movies
                              • Lifestyle
                                • Arts
                                • Culture
                                • Disabilities Matters
                                • Ethics & Religion
                                • Family
                                • Fashion
                                • Food
                                • Human Interest
                                • Tourism
                              • Opinion
                                • Editorials
                                • Letters to Editor
                                • John Mukum Mbaku
                                • Makau Mutua
                                • Peter Ongera
                                • Salim Lone
                                • XN Iraki
                              • Sci-Tech
                                • Climate Changes
                                • Cyber Security
                                • Technology
                                • Social Media
                                • Space
                              • Contact Us

                              © 2023 The Kenya Times | Our Privacy Policy | Standards and Policies | House Rules

                              Welcome Back!

                              Sign In with Facebook
                              Sign In with Google
                              Sign In with Linked In
                              OR

                              Login to your account below

                              Forgotten Password? Sign Up

                              Create New Account!

                              Sign Up with Facebook
                              Sign Up with Google
                              Sign Up with Linked In
                              OR

                              Fill the forms below to register

                              All fields are required. Log In

                              Retrieve your password

                              Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

                              Log In
                              Your Privacy and Cookies
                              We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies.
                              Do not sell my personal information.
                              Cookie settingsACCEPT
                              Privacy & Cookies Policy

                              Privacy Overview

                              This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
                              Necessary
                              Always Enabled
                              Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
                              Functional
                              Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features.
                              Performance
                              Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.
                              Analytics
                              Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
                              Advertisement
                              Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads.
                              Others
                              Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet.
                              SAVE & ACCEPT

                              Add New Playlist

                              Are you sure want to unlock this post?
                              Unlock left : 0
                              Are you sure want to cancel subscription?