Today’s world is heavily shaped by progressive thought. Much of it draws from a cluster of academic frameworks that analyse society through lenses of power, oppression, identity, and systemic structures. When translated into naive activist language, these ideas can feel compelling. But they are more persuasive than they are realistic tools for understanding the world. They have thrived in universities and public life partly because they speak to real frustrations while also hacking people’s psychology; they give people a clear villain, moral clarity, and a ready explanation for almost anything that goes wrong.
These theories are not stand-alone explanations. They borrow each other’s vocabulary, cite each other’s authors, and lend each other authority, so each seems confirmed by the others. Someone who has read only one or two rarely sees the shared foundation, and is more easily smitten. Below I outline the main ideas and where each one overreaches, misses parts of reality, or creates division by treating one explanation as nearly the whole story.
Marxist Theory
Karl Marx saw history as an ongoing struggle between social classes: the bourgeoisie (owners) and the proletariat (workers). Conflict, he argued, is built into the economic system itself, called capitalism, and he proposed overthrowing the existing order to create communism, a classless society. Later ideas and movements kept this basic story of systemic conflict and transformation.
Where it falls short: Marx predicted that capitalism would collapse under class conflict and give way to a classless utopia. In reality, capitalism adapted, raised living standards for ordinary people, and spread wealth more widely. Poverty remains, but more people escape it every year. Meanwhile, regimes that tried to put Marxist ideas into practice produced mass famines, purges, and economic failure. Deaths under 20th-century communist governments are estimated in the tens of millions. By reducing most problems to class oppression, the theory exaggerates one factor, downplays incentives and human nature, and keeps people locked in permanent class hostility.
Postmodernism
This broad movement questions objective truth, universal reason, and big stories about progress or science. It argues that language, power, and perspective shape knowledge and reality rather than fixed facts. It treats grand narratives about God, rights, science, logic, or human nature as tools of control.
Where it falls short: When truth, reason, and science are treated mainly as power plays, we lose the shared standards needed to identify real problems or measure progress. People come to believe that competing narratives are as valid as evidence, fracturing common ground and encouraging tribal conflict over basic facts. It elevates opinion to the status of knowledge; anyone who can string grammatical sentences together and speak confidently assumes they have knowledge.
Critical Theory
Developed largely by the Frankfurt School, this approach treats culture, institutions, and even ordinary social norms as systems of hidden domination. The goal is not just to describe society but to identify chains of bondage and free people from power structures. It views objective standards and liberal values with suspicion.
Also Read: Who Will Check IEBC’s Presidential Result in 2027?
Where it falls short: Marx called his socialism scientific; the Frankfurt School instead attacked science-modelled thinking as itself a tool of domination. Having rejected scientific method, the theory places itself beyond testing; it is largely unfalsifiable. If you disagree, your disagreement is dismissed as “inauthentic” or as “false consciousness.” The theory overstates hidden power as the main driver of social life while undervaluing evidence, trade-offs, and practical constraints. Feminism is older, going back to Wollstonecraft and the suffragists, but its academic strands absorbed this language of hidden domination, and the two now feed each other, with patriarchy as one more hidden system that explains everything. The result is more suspicion and division than shared problem-solving.
Critical Race Theory (CRT)
This academic and legal framework puts race at the centre of social analysis. It treats racism as primarily systemic (embedded in laws, institutions, and policies) rather than mainly a matter of individual prejudice. It rests on an oppressor-versus-oppressed framing; it reduces all problems faced by the perceived weaker race to the perceived stronger race. Disparities in outcomes are taken as evidence of ongoing racial power, and color-blind approaches are viewed with suspicion.
How These Theories Feed Off One Another
Where it falls short: It treats racial disparities as default proof of systemic racism while underweighting culture, behaviour, upbringing, age, geography, and differences in cognitive distributions. The framework often resists counter-evidence and ascribes ill will to those who challenge its conclusions. By making race the master explanation, it plants racial division and resentment even where other factors are doing most of the work. Its framing has also become a template for other oppressor-oppressed analyses.
Critical Pedagogy
Paulo Freire popularised this theory in Pedagogy of the Oppressed. It treats the classroom not only as a place to transmit knowledge but as a place to raise “critical consciousness” about power and oppression, encouraging teachers and students to identify and challenge what they call systems of inequality.
Where it falls short: It instrumentalises education and turns the learning space into a process of indoctrination. By putting consciousness-raising and activism ahead of knowledge and skills, it produces ideological conformity rather than competence: students become more fluent in broadcasting grievance than in the productive skills that actually expand opportunity. It also serves as the channel through which all the other progressive theories reach young minds.
Gender Theory
This theory holds that gender is a social and political construct, separate from biological sex and shaped by power relations. Drawing on feminist theory, it holds that male dominance created patriarchy as a systemic force that organises society. This system is hateful to women and seeks to oppress and devalue women. In resistance, many versions treat gender identities as fluid or performative and argue that traditional categories should be deconstructed.
Where it falls short: Biology shows that sex, defined by gametes, is a real binary in humans, and sex differences appear early and across cultures. From primitive times, humans recognised these differences and built gender around them, using it to divide roles, obligations, rewards, and privileges. Some societies allowed these to be swapped, but only on a small scale. Instead of accepting this description, gender theorists overreached, treating gender as an almost entirely socially constructed political system designed to dominate and oppress women. This opportunistic reframing of gender deludes people about biological realities (for example, in sports or medicine) and fuels conflict over sex-based categories and spaces.
Queer Theory
An extension of postmodern and gender ideas, this theory seeks to dismantle fixed categories of sex, gender, and sexuality. In this view, heteronormativity and binary distinctions are oppressive constructions enforced by social power. It persuades anyone who finds the obligations of their gender burdensome to revolt against them by adopting an alternative identity or even claiming to be genderless. The focus is on deconstructing norms (including those around marriage, reproduction and family) rather than expanding rights and obligations within existing categories.
Where it falls short: Queer theorists do not deny that most people are binary and heterosexual; they claim this pattern is a norm maintained by power. But a norm being common is not proof that it is oppressive and therefore should be reformed or overthrown. The pattern dominates because it is how our species functions, reproduces and raises its next generation. It was rooted in biology before any institution enforced it.
Also Read: Can IEBC Alter Constituency Presidential Results in 2027?
The theory preys on the anxiety people have about the obligations of their gender to incite them into rebellion against nature and society. It uses the tiny intersex population as an excuse to challenge the binary, though rare exceptions no more abolish a category than a child born with six fingers abolishes the five-fingered hand. Its logical end treats fluidity as the norm and frames ordinary human patterns as systemic domination.
Postcolonial Theory
This framework analyses Western civilisation’s historical and ongoing influence on the world. It treats knowledge, science, law, history, and cultural standards produced in the West as instruments of colonial power. It elevates non-Western perspectives as forms of resistance and reframes many Western achievements and institutions as systems of domination open to critique, and even replacement.
Where it falls short: It misses the fact that scientific methods are universal; they are not owned by any ethnicity. It downplays that many non-Western societies had their own hierarchies and violence. It also downplays the fact that post-independence outcomes often track governance, institutions, and culture more than residual “coloniality.” By over-explaining everything through colonial power, it fosters grievance, undercuts practical development, and plants anti-Western division.
Conclusion
These frameworks share a pattern: they treat power and systemic oppression as the primary drivers of social outcomes, while remaining sceptical of objective standards, individual agency, and multi-causal explanations. They also feed off each other, sharing concepts, methodologies, and inferences.
For instance, Marxism supplies the oppressor-versus-oppressed template, postmodernism dissolves the standards that could test it, Critical Theory turns it on culture, and the rest apply it to race, gender, sex, schooling, and history.
The loop is persuasive, but persuasiveness is not the same as accuracy. When a theory treats one lens as nearly total, it stops being a useful tool and becomes a source of distortion and division.
In the real world, culture, behaviour, incentives, biology, institutions, and individual choices shape outcomes, not just hidden systems of domination. Recognising these theories’ limits is not about dismissing real problems. It is about refusing to let one incomplete story crowd out better explanations and more practical ways forward.
George Nyongesa wrote this article. He is a lecturer in philosophy and logic at the University of Nairobi, the Technical University of Kenya and Chuka University.
Follow our WhatsApp Channel and X Account for real-time news updates and subscribe to our YouTube Channel for in-depth interviews.





